Does Meat Cause Disease?
I frequently point out in my writing and consultation that everything bad that happens to
the human body occurs downstream from inflammation, which leads to premature aging
and disease. Meat is frequently blamed as a source of inflammation. Agenda driven
food zealots would like nothing more than to plaster the news with headlines that meat
causes disease. There is published research from Harvard University that appears to
support that position. According to the study, Harvard researchers comparing the effects of plant-based diets to animal-based diets
discovered an inflammatory link with the meat-based diet. Of course they did, check out
what the meat-eating group ate! One of the researchers, Lawrence David, stated that
“Breakfast was eggs and bacon. Lunch was ribs and brisket, and then for dinner, it was
salami and prosciutto with an assortment of cheeses. The volunteers had pork rinds for
snacks.”
All meat is not created equal! The meat used in that research project wasn’t organic or
grass-fed, free-range, pasture-raised and was laden with preservatives, antibiotics,
hormones, high in omega 6 content from corn feeding and other contaminants. An
inflammatory response, in this case by altering gut microbiome, was identified and
probably could not have been avoided. No wonder the result was increased
inflammatory markers. Was the investigation a “set up” or just poor research design? It
almost appears that the feeding protocol was designed to result in that same
conclusion. We know that type of diet over time would result in many diseases like heart
disease, colon and other cancers, and many others. The anti-meat crowd gleefully
will cite this research. Unfortunately, most of the grocery store meat shares many of the
inflammatory characteristics as the meats in the Harvard study. If the headline read
“Preservative, Antibiotic, and Hormone Laden, High Omega 6 Content, Corn-Fed Meat
and Meat By-Products Cause Inflammation” I would buy it. Meat is healthy, genetically
compatible and body familiar UNLESS physiologically incompatible food and
contaminants (ex. Corn and chemicals) are introduced to the animal via feed or injection.
Even though the research conclusions were valid that does not mean that the results
could be honestly and practically applied to the question of whether meats are
inflammatory.
Research can be contorted and presented to support nearly any point of
view. If a research project was designed to study the results of sex on pregnancy and
the population to study was females 60 years and above the conclusion would be that
sex doesn’t lead to pregnancy. Accurate results, but the conclusion is faulty. Food
industry executives play the same game in the other direction providing false testament
as to the safety and quality of their products. Quite simply the organic label on USDA
inspected meats is misleading at best and often a joke. So, you must be cautious when
purchasing meats that are labeled organic, grass-fed, etc. The question becomes
who you can trust for the freshest, healthiest meats available?
Abstract link: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/nature12820.html
Wayne Coolidge M.Ed., Master Wellness Consultant. You can contact Wayne for
individual or corporate health/wellness consultation or speaking engagements